What to bring to an ACL second opinion

For a second opinion about a suspected or diagnosed anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury, bring the actual images and written reports from any knee scans you’ve already had, a short injury timeline, and a summary of the care you’ve tried. Add the question you most want answered. If a record is missing, tell our office what you have and ask how to share it. [1]
You might want to know whether you tore your ACL. Or you might understand the diagnosis but not why your knee still gives way, what physical therapy has changed, or why a particular treatment was suggested. Those are different reasons for an orthopedic second opinion. Asking for one does not commit you to changing doctors or having a procedure. It can also help you understand a plan you decide to continue with your current clinician. [2]
Ask for the image files as well as the report
If you had a knee MRI or X-rays, ask the facility that performed the exam for two things: the complete image study and the radiologist’s written report. The images let us look at the knee itself. The report tells us what the radiologist saw and thought was important. A photo of one MRI slice or a screenshot of the report’s conclusion is not the same as the complete study. Keep a copy of any images and reports you have, even if the imaging facility has shared them. [3] [4]
Before sending anything, ask our office how to share the actual image files. Tell us where and when the exam was done and which knee was scanned. If the facility says it already shared the study, ask whether the images and the report are both available for the visit. Being able to read a report yourself does not tell you whether another office can open the images. [5]
If you’ve had more than one exam, match each report to its date. Mark which studies took place before the injury, after it, or after a later episode when the knee felt different. If the report mentions a comparison with an older scan, note where that scan was done. That gives us a way to identify the earlier study if comparing the two would answer a question. [3] [4]
If all you have is a report, keep it. Mark the exact sentence you want explained, including words such as possible or partial. Tell the office whether you’ve requested the images or whether no scan was done in the first place. Those situations call for different conversations; neither is a reason to arrange another MRI on your own just to complete a checklist. [5] [6] Don’t wait until you have all your records to arrange an evaluation or follow time-sensitive advice from your treating clinician.
What can an MRI tell us, and what does the visit add?
An MRI can show the ACL and help us look for injuries to nearby tissues, including the meniscus, the cushion between the bones of the knee. X-rays answer a different question: they show bones rather than the ACL itself. An X-ray report that describes no fracture does not settle whether the ligament was injured. Our ACL tear overview explains what a partial or complete tear means. [6]
An MRI is not always necessary to diagnose an ACL tear, and a report describing a tear does not, by itself, choose your treatment. The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) recommends that clinicians ask about the injury and perform a focused physical examination. The scan can help us understand what was injured. Your account tells us what happens when you use the knee; the exam lets us assess how it moves and how stable it feels. [6] [7]
Write the timeline in your own words
Start with how your knee worked before this happened. Could you use stairs, work a full shift, or play your usual sport? Was the knee already painful, or had it given way before? Include an earlier injury or operation on that side. A sentence is enough. The point is to distinguish a new limitation from one you were already living with. [7]
Next, write down what you remember about the injury. Which foot was planted? Were you turning, landing, slowing down, or struck by something? Did you feel or hear a pop? Note when you first noticed swelling and whether you could keep walking or had to stop. If you don’t remember a detail, leave it open. An approximate date and an honest description are more useful than a precise account you’re unsure about. [7]
Then skip ahead to what has changed since. Perhaps the swelling settled, but the knee buckled when you turned around in the kitchen. Perhaps it hurts on stairs but has never actually given way. If the knee has caught during everyday activity, note what happened and what you were doing. Our guide to ACL symptoms can help you find words for what you felt. You don’t need to repeat a movement to prove it happens. [6] [7]
One distinction worth putting on paper: an activity you can do is different from one you haven’t tried. If you haven’t played since the injury, say that, rather than guessing whether your knee would hold up. Likewise, if it hasn’t buckled since you stopped turning quickly, mention both facts. Research supports considering the injury story alongside examination findings. [8]
Describe the care you actually received
Bring the earlier visit note or written recommendation if you have it. If not, jot down what you understood: what the clinician thought was injured, what they recommended, and what they wanted to reassess. Keep the recommendation separate from what happened afterward. For example, therapy may have been recommended at the first visit but started much later. That difference matters when we discuss how your knee responded. [1] [5]
For each treatment, use three short entries: what I tried, for about how long, and what changed. Include physical therapy, home exercises, a brace or crutches, medicines used for the knee, or an injection or procedure if you had one. If something helped, describe the benefit and how long it lasted. If you couldn’t try it because of pain, cost, transportation, or work hours, say so. A treatment you couldn’t start is not one that failed to help. [5]
For physical therapy, a recent progress note or exercise plan can be useful if it’s available. Your own example matters, too: going downstairs may now be easier, while turning to reach for something at work still feels uncertain. If you previously had knee surgery, note the side, approximate date, and procedure if known. An operative report, if you have it, can clarify what was done without asking you to remember the medical terms. [1] [5]
Keep a separate list of current medicines, doses, and how often you take them, including nonprescription medicines and supplements. Note allergies or unexpected reactions. The list is for discussion, not an instruction to stop or change anything. If instructions from two visits seem different, bring both and ask who should clarify what applies to you now. [1]
Name the decision you want help with
Try finishing this sentence before the visit: By the time I leave, I’d like to understand… Your answer might be whether the ACL explains the trouble you’re having, whether your therapy is addressing the right problem, or what information is still needed before you can compare options. Put that question at the top of your notes, where it won’t get lost among the reports.
Next, name an activity that matters to you in enough detail that we can picture it. Returning to work could mean sitting at a desk, carrying trays across a crowded room, or stepping down from a truck several times a day. Getting back to soccer could mean coaching from the sideline or playing in a competitive league. Tell us which parts you need to do, which you can modify, and which you most want back. Your goals belong in the treatment discussion alongside the findings. [6]
A work deadline or the start of a season is worth mentioning, but it is not the same as a medical return date. Ask what would need to improve before that activity is appropriate for you. If reconstruction has already been proposed, bring the reason you were given and the concern you still have. Our guide to what to know when considering ACL reconstruction covers that decision in more depth. [1] [6]
How we may put the pieces together
During the evaluation, we may compare your knees, check how far the injured knee bends and straightens, and examine its stability. We can consider those findings alongside the images, the earlier clinician’s assessment, and your account of daily life. If another structure is mentioned in the MRI report, ask us to show you where it is and explain whether it fits what you felt or changes the next step. [6] [7]
Consider a simple example. Suppose your MRI report describes an ACL tear. Since starting therapy, you can walk to the bus stop again, but you still take the elevator down because you don’t trust the knee on stairs. Rather than deciding on your own whether therapy has “worked,” bring both observations. We can discuss what has improved, what still limits you, and what the examination can tell us about that particular task. Your ability to walk to the bus and your concern about stairs both deserve an answer.
If two opinions sound different, ask where they differ. Do both clinicians see the same injury but recommend different next steps? Did the first clinician examine you before therapy, while the second is seeing you after your symptoms changed? Was an image unavailable at one visit? Asking each clinician to explain the reason for the recommendation gives you something more useful to compare than two treatment names. [2] [5]
Sometimes the useful answer is what we still don’t know. If another test or record is suggested, ask what specific question remains and what would change depending on the answer. Existing studies may be sufficient; sometimes they are not. Before you leave, write down the agreed next step, who will arrange it, and when or why to follow up. If you plan to return to your original clinician, ask how to get a summary you can discuss together. [1] [2] [5]
Planning your Santa Monica visit
Our Santa Monica office is at 2901 Wilshire Blvd, Suite 300, Santa Monica, CA 90403. If walking from the entrance is difficult or you need help planning the visit, ask the office about access ahead of time. If you’d like someone to take notes while you talk, consider bringing a friend or family member. Give them your main question beforehand so they know which answer you most want to remember. [1]
If you’re accompanying a young patient, ask what either of you should bring or fill out beforehand. If a clinician mentioned another injury in the same knee, ask whether notes or images about that injury would be useful, too.
Request an appointment or Call Dr. Millstein’s office at 310-595-1030.
ACL second-opinion checklist
- Images and reports: Actual knee MRI or X-ray files and matching reports, if available. Ask the office how to share the files.
- Timeline: Which knee, when and how it happened, early symptoms, and one example of how the knee feels now.
- Prior care: The earlier recommendation, what you actually tried, and what changed. Include relevant visit, therapy, or operative notes if available.
- Medication list: Names, doses, frequency, supplements, and allergies or reactions.
- Decision goal: The activity you need back, your most important question, and any missing record you want to ask about.
Questions to ask your physician
- Diagnosis: Which findings from my story, exam, and images support an ACL injury? What remains uncertain?
- Other findings: Can you show me whether the meniscus or another part of the knee was injured? Does it change what you recommend?
- Missing records: Would seeing the original images, an older study, or a prior operative note change your opinion? If you suggest new imaging, what would it answer?
- Prior treatment: What do you make of the improvement I’ve noticed and the activity I still can’t do? What should we track next?
- Options: Where does your opinion agree with the earlier recommendation? If it differs, which finding or goal makes the difference for me?
- Activity and recovery: What should I do about my current work, therapy, or sport restrictions? How will we decide when to change them?
- Medicines: Who should review my medication list and clarify any instructions that differ from what I was told before?
- Follow-up: Is there a decision I need to make now? Who should I contact with questions or a change in symptoms, and what should I take back to my treating clinician?
Sources
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS), OrthoInfo. Getting the Most Out of Your Visit With an Orthopaedic Surgeon. n.d. https://www.orthoinfo.org/treatment/surgical-treatment/getting-the-most-out-of-your-doctors-visit/
- AAOS. Second or Additional Medical Opinions in Orthopaedic Surgery. Revised December 2014. https://www.aaos.org/contentassets/6507ec63e5ac4ea48375ad96d154daac/l-3-opinion-on-second-or-additional-medical-opinions-rev-12-2014-color-logo.pdf
- RadiologyInfo.org. How to Obtain and Share Your Medical Images. Reviewed August 5, 2024. https://www.radiologyinfo.org/en/info/article-your-medical-images
- RadiologyInfo.org. All About Your Radiology Report: What to Know. Reviewed September 1, 2024. https://www.radiologyinfo.org/en/info/all-about-your-radiology-report
- AAOS, OrthoInfo. Your Visit With an Orthopaedic Surgeon. n.d. https://www.orthoinfo.org/diseases--conditions/adult-condition/your-visit-with-an-orthopaedic-surgeon/
- AAOS, OrthoInfo. Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) Injuries. n.d. https://www.orthoinfo.org/bodypart/kneelower-leg/anterior-cruciate-ligament-acl-injuries/
- AAOS. Management of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries: Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guideline. August 22, 2022. History and Physical. https://www.aaos.org/globalassets/quality-and-practice-resources/anterior-cruciate-ligament-injuries/aclcpg.pdf
- Décary S, et al. Clinical diagnosis of partial or complete anterior cruciate ligament tears using patients’ history elements and physical examination tests. PLOS ONE. June 12, 2018. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0198797